Sunday, September 1, 2013

Love Me Tonight

Love Me Tonight
Director: Rouben Mamoulian
Starring: Maurice Chevalier, Jeanette MacDonald, Charles Ruggles, Myrna Loy, C. Aubrey Smith

I admit, I’ve been holding off on writing a review of this film for the simple reason that I was saving it for a time when I really needed a pick me up.  With the next school year just around the corner, now seems as good a time as any for a cinematic happy pill, and by god, Love Me Tonight is most definitely a happy pill in film form.  I love this movie, perhaps to an almost irrational level, but I don’t care.  Love.  I LOVE Love Me Tonight.

Maurice (Chevalier) is a tailor living in Paris.  Princess Jeanette (MacDonald) is young widowed royalty living in the confines of a palace along with an elderly duke (Smith), several aunts, a boy-crazy young countess (Loy), and a womanizing viscount (Ruggles).  It is the viscount that Maurice first meets after the viscount stiffs Maurice on the bill for his latest suit.  Determined to get his money back, Maurice follows the viscount to the palace and poses as a baron, refusing to leave the viscount’s side until he gets his fee.  Problem is, he and the Princess Jeannette fall in love while he’s waiting for his money; whatever will happen when she realizes he’s not aristocracy?!?!?!?

I don’t even know where to begin.  It’s overwhelming, really.  Shit.

Alright, I’ll start at the opening of the film.  For my money, the first twenty minutes of Love Me Tonight are sheer perfection and beyond clever.  1932 was still fairly early in sound technology, but Mamoulian is remarkably wise with how he utilizes sound as a tool.  There are three songs in the first twenty minutes, almost making Love Me Tonight appear to be an operetta rather than a musical (it’s not), and these three songs are so smart.  First up, we open with a sleeping Paris.  Slowly, the city begins to awake, and it does so via sound.  Various vendors open their shops, families open their doors, and make all the normal, regular sounds of the city.  Thing is, Mamoulian builds a syncopated percussive song from all these sounds.  The bootmaker bangs his hammer in time with the woman fluffing her sheets.  Ultimately, the sounds become too cacophonous, and that’s when we meet our hero.  Maurice then walks down the street, saying hello to everyone and everything in the second song, and it’s a beautiful little scene that uses the song to further illustrate Parisian life. 

The third song in the opening twenty minutes is probably the best scene from the entire film, and one that’s been written about extensively.  Yes, I’m going to write about it too.  Maurice sings the famous “Isn’t It Romantic,” the first time that song appeared in film.  Maurice sings it in his shop, and the tune gets passed from Maurice to his customer to a taxi driver, etc.  As the song gets passed from person to person, it also travels from Maurice’s shop to, eventually, Jeanette’s palace, where she hears it and then sings a verse.  I love love love this scene.  It’s a remarkable way of connecting the hero and heroine before they’ve even met, making it clear to us, the audience, that these two are meant for one another even though they’ve never met.  It’s a brilliant use of song, utterly clever, showing how the song evolves and travels from person to person and situation to situation, changing in each interpretation.  It’s a military march when the soldiers sing it, a happy tune when Maurice introduces it, and full of slightly melancholic longing when Jeanette sings it.  It’s rightly remembered as the most famous scene of the film; it’s brilliant.

The songs, in fact, are one of the biggest draws of this film for me.  I make it clear that I am a fan of musicals, but I’ve also written several times about how I greatly prefer musicals where the songs are woven within the plot and story rather than “backstage musicals” where the focus is on “putting on a show.”  Love Me Tonight is one of THE best, if not THE best early in-plot musicals.  Nearly the entire plot is somehow syncopated – butlers enter rooms walking to the beat of the soundtrack music, Maurice runs upstairs in time with the tune, characters even talk in rhyme half the time – and yet it works.  The story is an utter fantasy, as are most romantic comedies, so why not indulge all the way?  Let’s be honest, I’m not looking for reality when I watch Love Me Tonight, so I embrace its flights of fancy, including how it handles the in-plot songs. 

Chevalier is utterly sparkling as he essentially plays himself.  Although much younger here than the Chevalier that most Americans think of (re: the dirty old man who sings “Thank Heaven for Little Girls” from Gigi in 1958), he was still in his early forties when Love Me Tonight was made, hardly a young flower.  Still, there’s something about seeing a younger, more energetic, broad-chested Chevalier that, I admit, I find very appealing.  He works as my romantic hero here.  And when he sings “Mimi,” I melt.  I love pre-Code films, and Love Me Tonight is pre-Code.  The sexual innuendo woven into nearly every other line of dialogue is sparkling, and Chevalier was born for these lines.  “Mimi,” a song Maurice sings to Jeanette the first time they meet as he tries to woo her, is nothing more than him saying, “Hey, you’re cute, wanna fuck?”  Now this on its own tickles me (dirty!), but it’s made even better because Chevalier sings it straight to camera.  It’s not done in a two-shot, but with Chevalier making direct eye contact with the audience.  I smile so broadly when he sings the final verse, “You know I want to have a little son of a Mimi by and by,” but hardly gets out the words because of all the winks and eyebrows and nods he’s throwing in, making it PERFECTLY clear what he’s REALLY singing about.  Yes, Maurice IS Chevalier, but for crying out loud, it’s fun watching Chevalier here.  

Additionally, although I’m not a huge Jeanette MacDonald fan, I really think the chemistry between Maurice and Princess Jeanette (and christ, I love that they named the main characters after the actors, that’s too funny) works.  It’s actually mostly because of Chevalier.  MacDonald is her typical MacDonald swooning self, with one notable exception that I will mention later on, but Chevalier is unexpectedly shy and timid in certain scenes.  When he finally makes a serious move on Princess Jeanette, kissing her for the first time at the masquerade ball, she slaps him and he sadly shrugs, far too sadly for my heart to handle, and he moves to go away.  When she stops him and kisses him back, I can see him utterly light up, thinking that he lost what he wanted but now finds it’s back.  And when he brokenly, laughingly tells her that he loves her, you can read his utter disbelief all over his face when she says his love is returned.  He makes it so painfully clear that he is aware of their discrepancy in ranks, although she is not, and he also knows that this utter dream of his will not and cannot last.  It has the heartbreaking poignancy of a man desperately clutching to a wish that cannot be fulfilled.  

Yes, Chevalier isn’t exactly the finest actor to grace the planet, but his handling of the few scenes that require real emotion in Love Me Tonight utterly wins me over.  I feel the chemistry, I feel the love, I get that coiling in my stomach that tells me I am really, truly rooting for this couple to get together.  And later on, when the charade is up (WAIT, A COMPLICATION IN A ROMANTIC COMEDY?  SURELY YOU JEST) and Maurice finally tells Princess Jeanette he is “just” a tailor instead of a baron, Chevalier makes my heart break.  He looks towards the camera and says, utterly crestfallen, “Does that make so much difference?” as Jeanette backs away in horror.  This sad, broken man, who knows that he just lost his love, is shockingly poignant.  The movie is such an utter soufflé for its vast majority, and throwing in this tiniest moment of loss and sadness somehow grounds the rest of the film for me.  It makes their love and his loss feel real in a film filled with fantasy.  The first time I watched Love Me Tonight, I was loving it from the get go, but when it got to this particular scene, that’s when I really fell, and I fell hard.  I love the silliness and the giddiness of the musical scenes and all the snappy, sassy quips, but Chevalier’s simple performance when he outs himself to the Princess just pushes it over the edge for me.

And none of this has anything to do with the supporting cast.  Love Me Tonight is easily in the running for one of the best assemblies of a supporting cast ever.  C. Aubrey Smith as the duke is hysterical as he constantly gets his guests to play bridge and even sings a bit.  Charles Ruggles, billed as Charlie Ruggles, nearly steals every scene he’s in as the broke viscount, constantly trying to hit on every woman he meets.  And Myrna Loy.  I mean, I already adore Myrna Loy with the passion of a thousand flames, and seeing her vamp it up here with some of the juiciest lines in the film is joyous.  The snappy dialogue everyone gets to toss around is ridiculously fun, such as when the viscount asks Myna Loy if she could go for a doctor, to which she replies, “Why yes, send him right in!” as she adjusts her dress.  As I’ve stated above, I really rather love the two main characters, but Love Me Tonight is not just about Maurice and Jeanette.  Everyone else who peoples this odd little fantasy universe is hysterical, snappy, and sassy.  It’s a brilliant cast.

I’ve mentioned in at least one other review a particular quirk of mine.  We all have them, little things that we particularly love or hate, thematic elements that make us either predisposed to loving or hating a film.  They don’t always have to make a lot of sense or even be major plot elements, but if a film has one, it can elicit a strong reaction.  A rather big quirk of mine in romantic comedies is one relating to gender.  I am strongly predisposed to loving a rom com if, in the finale, it is the woman who chases after the man.  It’s about choice; typically, when a guy has to go after a girl, as is the case in 98% of all rom coms, I sometimes read it as the woman having no other options, so she guesses she’ll take this guy back even though he was kind of a dick.  This implies she doesn’t have any other options; she’d better take this one because who knows if anyone else will ever come along?  Or, on the other hand, why is it the guy who always has to apologize?  Why is it always the guy who’s mucking up and has to humble himself to get the girl?  Are all men such dolts?  No, they’re not; women mess up too, y’know, and women admit they made mistakes too.  Do I dislike all rom coms that follow this very traditional path?  No, of course not, but every now and then when I come across one that switches the “Prince Charming Saving The Princess” stereotype in the finale, I am almost automatically a fan.  It puts the woman in a position of power, of choosing to fight for her relationship, of having the choice about being in the relationship because she wants to be and not simply because it’s convenient.  The fact that Love Me Tonight has Jeanette fighting for her man, choosing to be with Maurice after he’s left, AND that this is 1932, is fantastic.  It gives Jeanette an incredible amount of power; she shifts from being a wilting flower to a wild animal in the finale of the film.  And I fucking love that.  She realizes she has fallen in love, and also that she has mishandled the situation pretty badly and chased Maurice away.  So she grits her teeth and fights for Maurice, stopping a frickin’ train in its tracks in order to get her beloved back.  Fuck yeah, Jeanette!  You go, girl!

Um, so in case the previous 2100 words (!!) haven’t yet convinced you, I really really love this movie.  It’s so happy, the musical numbers are immensely clever and naughty, it has just the right dose of pleasantly poignant emotions, it’s witty beyond all measure, AND it even manages a bit of grrl power just to add the frosting to the cake!  I’ve seen it more times than I can count and I don’t tire of it.  An absolute favorite, no doubt.

Arbitrary Rating: 10/10.  Top 25 films of all time, easy.  Might even make an argument for Top 10.  LOVE.


  1. Ready for a shock? You know my dislike of musicals as a rule, and I really enjoyed this film a lot more than I thought I would. A lot of this is the effective staging of the musical numbers ("Isn't it Romantic?" is pure genius, and I really enjoyed Jeanette McDonald singing a love song to her horse). It's also got genuinely funny moments. I don't love McDonald's singing style, but she had solid comic timing, and the film really works because of it.

    And that is why I watch everything on The List.

    1. You are not the first (nor, I believe, the last) person I've come across who generally dislikes musicals but actually likes Love Me Tonight. Like Singin' In the Rain, Love Me Tonight seems to be a musical that people make exception for. Is it as good as Singin' In the Rain? Well, no, but what is? But it's so much fun, very clever, and yes, gosh, she sings classical music to her horse!

      I love opera, but MacDonald's shrieking vibrato tends to grate on me as well. It's not nearly annoying enough to put me off the film, though. AWESOME!!!

  2. It's scary how much we have in common when it comes to movies! I have a YouTube clip from Love Me Tonight on a Pinterest page and have revisited it more times than I can count. You are right about watching when you need a lift. I also adore the reprise of Mimi with the different characters singing the song.

    Mamoulian directed Porgy and Bess on Broadway and the opening of this film is sort of echoed by the staging of the street vendors cries in the morning on Catfish row. I think Mamoulian was a bit of a genius but he evidently pissed a lot of people off as his career came to an early end.

    I really like the pre-Nelson Eddie Jeanette MacDonald. She is wonderful in all the pre-Code Lubitsch musicals as well.

    1. I have watched the Isn't It Romantic clip more times than I can count. It's absolutely brilliant.

      (yes, I have also noticed we have similar tastes... this makes me happy...)

      When I rewatched Love Me Tonight while writing this review, I had forgotten about the reprise of Mimi sung by the other characters, and I literally doubled over in laughter. I had forgotten about that big, and it's sublime.

      I'm definitely with you on pre-Nelson Eddie MacDonald. I really think it's that combo (Eddie and MacDonald) that I'm not as keen on. Chevalier and MacDonald is absolutely sparkling.

  3. I meant to say that the clip I have is "Isn't It Romantic?" It holds up well to frequent rewatching. Flawless.

  4. Thanks for the reminder on the scene with the song travelling from person to person. It brought back the scene for me. I enjoyed this movie, probably not quite as much as you, but plenty enough to put a smile on my face.

    You know what? I also appreciate it when it's not the man who has to apologize for whatever contrived and/or imagined slight he made. I don't really care about who is the pursuer, but sometimes the lengths writers go to to have the man apologize are ridiculous. Christ, I saw a film about 10 years ago where the man was literally raped and he had to run after the woman and apologize profusely for "cheating" on her. I was in disbelief when I saw it, but I figured it was a gender thing and maybe a woman wouldn't consider it rape. A couple days later a female co-worker mentioned she had seen the film and almost the first words out of her mouth were, "He was friggin' raped!" I just responded, "Thank you!" I felt relief that it wasn't something a woman would let the moviemakers slide on, either.

    On a completely different topic, I emailed you a while back regarding foreign films on the list. Did you receive it?

    1. Just replied! Apologies - end of the summer is a shite time for me.

      I'm glad you like this movie too. It honestly warms my heart to know that most people who've seen it seem to really enjoy it.

      And YES re: gender roles. For me, I definitely appreciate the "grrl power" angle first and foremost, but I also get tired of the man constantly having to apologize for himself. Because seriously, men are not nearly the bumbling dolts Hollywood would have us believe they are. It's a stereotype that doesn't get as much discussion as others, but a stereotype nonetheless. And your example is even more egregious, as its not just goofy actions, but rape.


      YES! Love Me Tonight, winner winner chicken dinner!

  5. Great review. No surprise this one is up there with me as well, converting me to a musical lover. Since I saw Love Me Tonight I have noticed how often Isn't It Romantic shows up even today. Talk about an evergreen.
    Your second to last paragraph really stands out and I applaud you. This is exactly what changes an ordinary (and usually forgettable) rom-com to something special. Rom-coms are so prone to stereotypes and clichés almost as if they were essential elements to the fomular. Who says genderroles are cut in stone? I love it when a film dares to play with those roles, especially when they make the female leads strong and resourceful. Too often when it happens the film makes them simply stomp on everybody else to get their often infantile ways, but here in Love Me Tonight Jeanette takes her fate in her own hand and does what needs to be done, apology and all.
    Curiously Mamoulian follow the same track in Queen Christina.

    1. Thanks so much for the comment! The gender roles issue is one I first began noticing about five or six years ago, and since then, it's something I pay a lot of attention to. I love finding it in older films, as it's evidence of forward thinking!

      I like that everyone likes this film. It's a worthy one.